When my book club picked I Who Have Never Known Men, I wasn’t sure what to expect. I had heard it was unsettling, thought-provoking, and unlike anything else, exactly the kind of book that sparks great discussions. And wow, did it deliver. Jacqueline Harpman’s novel is one of those stories that lingers, making you question everything you take for granted about knowledge, culture, and what it means to be human. I realized just how much of our world is built on the stories and histories we inherit, and what happens when those are stripped away.
Jacqueline Harpman’s I Who Have Never Known Men is a haunting meditation on the ways in which knowledge, particularly social and cultural knowledge, shapes our understanding of the world and our very identities. Through the unnamed narrator, a girl raised in absolute isolation from society, the novel challenges us to consider what it means to be human when stripped of the context that defines us.
The protagonist has no memory of life outside a locked bunker, where she exists alongside thirty-nine older women, all of whom have lived in the outside world before being imprisoned. Unlike them, she has never known anything else. She has no concept of men, love, family, or history. Her knowledge is limited to the present, and what she learns is only what the other women can describe to her. When she eventually escapes into a desolate world devoid of other humans, she is left with nothing but her own curiosity, struggling to construct meaning in a world that offers no explanations.
Harpman’s novel is a powerful commentary on the ways in which culture is transmitted. The protagonist’s lack of cultural inheritance leaves her adrift; she is unable to fully comprehend what she has lost because she never had it to begin with. Her experience forces us to reflect on the deep impact of history, tradition, and interpersonal relationships in shaping not just knowledge but also emotion and connection.
In the absence of societal norms and shared understanding, the narrator must define life for herself. This raises a profound question: How much of what we consider essential to being human, is it our morality, our relationships, our desires, and is it learned rather than innate? In a world without past or future, without a common language of experience, can one truly live rather than merely exist?
The novel also critiques the arbitrary structures of power and control. The imprisonment of the women, overseen by faceless guards who never explain their motives, mirrors the way authority often operates without justification. The protagonist’s freedom, when it finally comes, is not a triumphant escape but an entrance into a void. If culture and history are erased, then what remains of civilization?
Harpman’s sparse, almost clinical prose mirrors the starkness of the world she describes, emphasizing the loneliness of her protagonist’s journey. Yet, despite the bleakness, there is something deeply moving in the narrator’s relentless search for meaning. Her determination to understand, even when there are no answers, suggests an inherent human drive to seek knowledge, to piece together fragments of understanding even in the face of total uncertainty.
I Who Have Never Known Men asks us to consider the fragile nature of our own knowledge. So much of what we believe to be intrinsic to us is constructed through the cultural frameworks we inherit, that is our sense of identity, our moral compass, our relationships. When those are stripped away, what remains? Are we still ourselves? Harpman’s novel leaves us with an unsettling but vital thought: perhaps we are only as human as the stories we tell each other.
Featured Image by Braden Collum on Unsplash
